I’ve only seen it in the s thread once, and just up voting it didn’t seemed enough. I’ve played the majority of games people are mentioning here, some of them are quite sad and hit you like a punch in the stomach. Another one I also didn’t cried but felt very strongly about it and I don’t think I’ve seen it mentioned here was Life is Strange, there’s one particular scene that got me very hard.
All of this is to say, I don’t usually cry on movies, books or games, it’s not a “boys don’t cry” kind of thing, I don’t have a problem with crying or with getting in touch with my feelings, I just don’t cry very often or for any reason. However, I don’t know if it was the story on its own or the blinking mechanic but Before your eyes had me crying, and wasn’t just a couple tears either, I only held myself together because I couldn’t leave the game until it finished. That game was an experience, I recommend going in blind and using the camera.
Outer wilds for sure. Halo reach. Borderlands 2. Definitely others, I’m always wrecked by heroic sacrifice
I have sensitive eyes. Any modern AAA graphics makes them go red instantly and my eyes start leaking within 30 minutes.
Last of us part 2.
To the moon.
I may have teared up at the end of Half-Life 2.
I was full on ugly crying at the end of To The Moon.
Lol, I tear up just hearing River’s song, it’s such an amazing story. We also played Laura Shigihara’s cover of “Everything’s alright” for my wife walking down the isle. It’s a special game.
That rules
“Jade Shadows” quest in Warframe.
Ayyyyy, fellow Warframe player! Not too many of us in the wild, huh?
Not on Lemmy at least.
Stray had some moments
The end of Stray killed me
Beginning of Stray: “Oh, this cat game is so cute!”
End of Stray: [Hey, come see this big, grown-ass adult guy start ugly-crying!]
MGS4…
Everyone Dies. You can’t stop it. You can’t run from it. Let me tell you something… Don’t… Don’t waste the life you have left fighting.
- Big Boss
The metroidvania, Ori series.
Ori and the blind forest & Ori and the will of the wisps
The end of Will of the Wisps damn near killed me from dehydration
Maybe an outside one here, but when Dragon Age: Origins was still new, I was much younger and hadn’t had a serious girlfriend yet. And in general, I got quite a bit more attached to characters in games, including the romantic interests especially.
Spoilers ahead if you haven’t beaten the game
spoiler
At the end of the game, my character died and I had romanced the character Leliana. The end screen shows a somber note about Leliana being heartbroken and wandering the world missing the character.
Something about that really struck something in me and made me extremely sad. I think it’s probably the only time I’ve ever really cried because of a video game.
I can’t actually find a reference to this ending online. The wiki isn’t 100% complete. Otherwise, I would have linked the blurb here.
Now a days I struggle to connect with characters in games. They will never be as real as my friends or my partner, so it’s hard to form such an emotional connection as I did when I was a teenager.
Yeah, I once walked into a Gamestop and saw how expensive new games have gotten…
Joking aside:
-
Journey
-
To the Moon
-
Spiritfarer
-
Ori and the Will of the Wisps
All good games, I can’t recommend them enough.
God … Spiritfarer. What an amazing experience. I didn’t cry but quite a few times I had to put down the controller and just stare out the window. It’s not sad but it is so sad. It’s so wistful and god just loved that game.
Ooh can you tell me a bit more about spiritfarer? I bought it excitedly a few months ago but stuff happened and I didn’t play it for a long time. And now I find it kinda hard to get back to it. Also I seen to be stuck with some basic early missions
Stovetop gives a great explanation of the mechanics so I’ll just add about the vibes. Spiritfarer is sweet and kind at its heart. The main interface of the game is giving hugs and cooking the favourite foods of your passengers. You explore both physically in your boat and in the lives of your friends, and hopefully you come to understand a little bit about life and death. And patience too, sometimes you’re not really stuck you’re just not ready yet.
hopefully you come to understand a little bit about life and death
This is precious what made me buy it. This and the beautiful visuals. I will for sure give it another shot!
Not the previous poster, but I’ll share what I can. And I’m assuming you already know the premise from the store page, but to provide context to others:
Spiritfarer is a chill meditation on the nature of death. Due to random circumstances, the main character (and her cat) take over for the mythological figure of Charon and are now tasked with ferrying the dead. So over the course of the game, you encounter a number of notable spirits, who each have their own stories to learn. But you don’t need to bring them to their final destination until they’re ready to go, so in the meantime they just kinda join your crew and hang out.
Mechanically, Spiritfarer is a resource management game. You upgrade your boat with buildings that serve a particular purpose, like gardens, a kitchen, a blacksmith, etc. and use resources grown on the ship or found at various islands to craft materials needed for upgrades and some quest turn-ins. Some key upgrades for the boat are needed to progress to other parts of the map, where more things become accessible over time.
In terms of what makes the game appealing, it’s almost entirely vibes-based. None of the resource management mechanics feel rushed or stressful, so it’s easy for people to proceed at their own pace. It also supports 2P multiplayer, where player 2 plays as the cat and can do everything P1 can. The spirits your encounter provide mechanical benefits to your boat, but also have their own stories to learn that reveals more about who they were in life—often more tragic than one would initially assume. But I think the main emotional gut punch of the game is knowing that the spirits need to move on eventually. You’re just trying to help them find closure first. And often, they’re ready to go when you’re not ready to say goodbye yet.
So I recommend it as a game to play in small spurts, but I wouldn’t go too long in between sessions. For me, it made for some good unwind time after some long days of work. And if you have someone else to do couch co-op with, I think it’s a good game for couples. But if you put it down and don’t come back for a while, it can be easy to forget what things you were working on. It’s not a hard game, so probably not too much effort to figure out your way back on track, but it might be worth restarting if you’re still at the beginning.
Ooh, thank you very very much for the detailed reply. I think I should just restart the campaign. I do really being awed by the visuals of the game, with all the handdeawm graphics.
I think the part where I was stuck was that I needed to find something on the map marked by a snake, but I never found the marker and the resource management seemed a bit grind-y. But anyway, I think I’ll give it a shot again. In general I’m a bit new to gaming and getting used to some of the repetitive(?) mechanics
If you’re ever feeling stuck, it never hurts to look up a guide! I’m not a fan of Fandom, but their Spiritfarer wiki does appear to include walkthroughs for most of the quests if you’re not sure what to do or where to go next.
It’s not sad but it is so sad
After
spoiler
Atul ::: I literally had to put the game down for weeks because I couldn’t stop crying whenever I tried. I think it certain parts just hit different depending on your experiences with grief.
Yeah Atul …
Atul
Sometimes you don’t get to say goodbye and that sucks. One day they’re just gone. But with Atul I kept it together because the reason he just disappeared was that he didn’t need us. He could go to the door on his own and yeah he should have said goodbye at least but … well it sucks but I like to remember the happy frog at the party.
For me it was Stanley and Alice
Alice
God it was heartbreaking watching her mind slowly dissolve and get lost. That’s where it hit me how important Stella’s job was. How important having someone with her at the end, helping and not even saying anything just being there is. I couldn’t do it but I’m grateful for the people who can.
Stanley
Fuck as a parent that got me. Fuck you god! I know that life isn’t fair but that really wasn’t fair. And watching his mom fall apart from his eyes … Her ‘Fakenegs’ … her fear in watching his fear … I’ve never been tested like that and I hope I could do better but man I understand her failing.
What touched you about Journey? I finished the games about 3 times and honestly can’t recall that much about it but the art/graphic design being top notch.
Regarding OP’s question I also don’t recall a game that has made me cry yet, but I wouldn’t say I am a senseless being lol, some anime scenes get me from time to time… Is just that with games it feels different.
There were a few things, I think. Stylistically I thought it was gorgeous and made well, coupled with the absolutely beautiful soundtrack by Austin Wintory. But I also got lucky my first time though, and ended up sticking with the same partner pretty much from the very beginning all the way through the end.
The argument that games are art is something that was pretty widely discussed around the release of Journey, but what I think made that game in particular so impactful is the way that it took a basic mechanic like multiplayer support and wove it so perfectly in with the narrative it was trying to tell. Walking into the light with the same person who was with me from so early on, after everything we went through, and then saying our goodbyes before that beautiful OST played through the credits, it was pretty moving.
To the moon is like a kick right in the feels. Had me and my wife in bits at the ending.
-
Cyberpunk, but only because that fucking song came on the radio.
Witch one?
Have you watched edgerunners?
Ahh I know the song you’re talking about now!
Thomas was Alone. Cried over quadrilaterals.
Oh gosh, it’s been so long since I played, but I remember doing the same.
To be honest, there were a ton of PS3 games that wrecked me. Papa y Yo, Brothers, Journey.
Detroit become human, that game is art.
I’ve teared up for some. In Sound Mind made me think of my cat who was recently deceased and was more special to me than any of the other pets I had. And then there was the ending for Outer Wilds, and the… fuckin’ everything in Ori and the Blind Forest.
Oh, and the second one.
spoiler
“…When my name was Ori.”
Both Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2 made me cry.
