• 0 Posts
  • 61 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: June 7th, 2025

help-circle

  • It’s the cornerstone of interacting with your local community in the UK.

    No it isn’t. My interactions with my local community never take place in a pub. I don’t think I know anyone who would consider the pub to be the “cornerstone of their interacting” with anybody at all, local community or otherwise. Frankly your description seems bizarre.

    You don’t even have to drink, it’s a cozy, generally quiet place to socialise.

    This doesn’t accord with my experience at all. I’d feel very out of place if I just hung around in a pub for any length of time without buying anything. Pubs aren’t social centres, they’re businesses.













  • the point was the UK is not the only one trying to do it

    I don’t see any evidence of the EU trying to do with the GDPR what the UK is trying to do with the Online Safety Act.

    they can totally enforce the fine by restricting those businesses from doing business within their territory until they comply

    That’s sanctioning, not enforcing a fine.

    And yes they can do that but that’s not what Ofcom is talking about. Ofcom have explicitly stated that foreign citizens have “duties” under UK law. The word “duty” has a very specific meaning in English law, in fact it’s really one of the most basic concepts. It means there is an obligation on someone and if that obligation is not fulfilled then courts have the power to take action.

    Sanctioning a foreign citizen doesn’t imply an obligation. There can’t be an obligation because a foreign citizen, by definition, is not subject to English law. Ofcom is claiming that foreign citizens are subject to English law.

    I don’t know how you could get it more wrong.

    LOL



  • Fine companies in other countries

    Firstly, then GDPR is legislation, it can’t act in the world, like fine people. I presume you’re referring to the EU and not the GDPR.

    Secondly, the EU has no power in “other” countries, by which I presume you mean non-EU countries. It’s not possible for the EU to fine companies in non-EU countries. They could issue a fine but they have no power to enforce or collect the fine. The non-EU companies can quite legally just laugh at the EU and give them the finger.