I’m sure this is a super common question but why do people (generally liberals or sometimes people on the left) call basically everyone who mildly agree with current more authoritarian leaning socialist states tankies

I wouldn’t nessicarily call myself a tankie but I can also fully understand why people feel that label fits them when so many people call so many perspectives tankie perspectives and just shove them in a corner

Not sure if that makes sense as a question but I hope it does

  • Lemvi@lemmy.sdf.org
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    7 days ago

    I keep being surprised that people on here seem to have an issue with that nickname. Have a look at the lemmygrad logo.

    I think tanks as a visual symbol of authoritarianism kinda make sense. No idea where the link to socialism comes from though.

    • -6-6-6-@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      6 days ago

      No idea where the link to socialism comes from though.

      From actually existing socialist nations and not from LARP newspaper orgs or chauvinistic anarchists who have yet to form an actual socialist project that is both successful and lasting.

    • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      edit-2
      6 days ago

      “Tankie” was a pejorative for Marxists that support socialism in real life then as well as now. It originated in the Communist Party of Great Britain. The term was coined because of the British tendency towards silly-sounding insults, and because the Soviet Union sent in the Red Army to stop the western-backed fascist insurrection. This caused a split in the party (as it always does in western orgs).

      The Hungarian revolt in 1956 was infested with anti-semitic pograms. MI6 funded, supplied, and trained the Hungarian counter-revolutionaries. These counter-revolutionaries were allied with fascists who were lynching Jewish people and Communists. The Truth About Hungary by Herbert Aptheker, heavily relies on citing western sources like the New York Times (which you can see if you actually read my comment). Aptheker backs up his claims heavily.

      "The special correspondent of the Yugoslav paper, Politika, (Nov. 13, 1956) describing the events of those days, said that the homes of Communists were marked with a white cross and those of Jews with a black cross, to serve as signs for the extermination squads. “There is no longer any room for doubt,” said the Yugoslav reporter, “it is an example of classic Hungarian fascism and of White Terror. The information,” continued this writer, “coming from the provinces tells how in certain places Communists were having their eyes put out, their ears cut off, and that they were being killed in the most terrible ways.”

      “But the forces of reaction were rapidly consolidating their power and pushing forward on the top levels, while in the streets the blood of scores of massacred Communists, Jews, and progressives was flowing.”

      “Some of the reports reaching Warsaw from Budapest today caused considerable concern. These reports told of massacres of Communists and Jews by what were described as 'Fascist elements’ …” (N.Y. Times, Nov. 1. 1956)

      “The evidence is conclusive that the entry of Soviet troops into Budapest stopped the execution of scores, perhaps thousands of Jews, for by the end of October and early November, anti-Semtic pogroms - hallmark of unbridled fascistic terror - were making their appearance, after an absence of some ten years, within Hungary.”

      "A correspondent of the Israeli newspaper Maariv (Tel Aviv) reported:

      During the uprising a number of former Nazis were released from prison and other former Nazis came to Hungary from Salzburg . . . I met them at the border . . . I saw anti-Semitic posters in Budapest . . . On the walls, street lights, streetcars, you saw inscriptions reading: “Down with Jew Gero!” “Down with Jew Rakosi!” or just simply “down with the Jews!”

      Leading rabbinical circles in New York received a cable early in November from corresponding circles in Vienna that “Jewish blood is being shed by the rebels in Hungary.” Very much later-in February, 1957-the World Jewish Congress reported that “anti-Semitic excesses occurred in more than twenty villages and smaller provincial towns during the October-November revolt.” This occurred, according to this very conservative body, because “fascist and anti-Semitic groups had apparently seized the opportunity, presented by the absence of a central authority, to come to the surface.” Many among the Jewish refugees from Hungary, the report continued, had fled from this anti-Semitic pogrom-like atmosphere (N.Y. Times, Feb. 15, 1957). This confirmed the earlier report made by the British Rabbi, R. Pozner, who, after touring refugee camps, declared that “the majority of Jews who left Hungary did so for fear of the Hungarians and not the Russians.” The Paris Jewish newspaper, Naye Presse, asserted that Jewish refugees in France claimed quite generally that Soviet soldiers had saved their lives."

      Further, the CIA also backed Hungarian resistance forces:

      Prague in 1968 was a similar fascist uprising in both cases there were some elements of progressive protest, but these were greatly overshadowed by the fascist movements. Dubcek wanted to sell out to the IMF, and restore capitalism. The idea that any of this was about “democracy” or “freedom” is silly, it was always about Cold War tactics to destabilize socialism.

      TL;DR imagine if the January 6th rioters were armed and trained by foreign governments, started lynching officials and Jewish people, and the US sent in the army to put down the insurrection. The MAGA chuds would claim that it was about “freedom” and “democracy,” but we all know that they just wanted Trump in office.

      Nowadays, it’s used by any random anti-communist to refer to anyone that supports socialist states or doesn’t buy into the imperialist narrative about global south countries. It was the ones you call “tankies” that knew the stories of WMD and Saddam’s forces leaving babies outside of incubators were both bullshit to manufacture consent for war, but now that its decades later the anti-communists all suddenly have collective amnesia about their willing participation in spreading the lies of empire to murder hundreds of thousands of people.

      I recommend the Prolewiki article on “Tankies,” as well as Nia Frome’s essay “Tankies.” That should give you a more well-rounded view.

      • -6-6-6-@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        edit-2
        6 days ago

        and of course, like most radlibs, they probably don’t/didn’t read or don’t care and continue gurgling State Department truth like it’s the sweet, sweet nectar of life.

        Maybe they did, but I can’t help but feel like this beautifully written passage fell on deaf ears.

          • -6-6-6-@lemmygrad.ml
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            5 days ago

            That’s good. I have had a lot of experience with talking to red maga and blue maga and genuinely radlibs are the hardest to break-through to. I really don’t know what it is that makes some radlibs go hardcore on the U.S state department garbage. I had a talk with one this morning about China and even if you just ram statistics and sources into their face they’re full-tilt on the “perfidious asians” even if they don’t say it like that.

            Shit is frustrating, thanks for you service Cowbee!

    • darkernations@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      edit-2
      7 days ago

      We wear the name with pride as we understand socialism is a science, not the empty idealism of racist Westerners who are more than happy to echo the imperialist talking points and look down their nose on the systems of socialist governance of the Global South that attempt to withstand the ongoing brutal siege by the West.

      If you actually want to learn:

      https://redsails.org/why-marxism/