Basically, wanted to know where people are at with mask wearing (as it relates to containing covid and all), I know it’s been a while since it started. And I’ve seen people who say covid can still be threatening, like through long covid and such, even if the initial impact doesn’t tend to be as bad. Being in the US, it’s especially hard to tell what makes sense because the gov sorta gave up on containment a while back and only ever half-assed pushing mask wearing. And wearing a mask alone was a controversial thing in some places, even in the very beginning. Then there’s vaccines, which of course help, but seems to be a thing like the flu where you have to get boosters to be fully covered for variant strains.
So in general, I’m wondering stuff like:
-
Do you still wear a mask or not and why? And do you have distinctions like large crowds or anything like that?
-
How does mask wearing compare by country, from what you know? For example, I’m sure China has a more pro-mask-wearing culture and policy overall, but I’m not clear on where they’re at this late into it.
Partly asking cause I want to re-assess my own position on it, see if it makes sense to change it at all by now. I’ve still been doing it, in part out of inertia, but the US management of it is such a mess, in gov and culture, it’s hard to tell when it makes sense to stop vs. just caving to peer pressure of people who were never acting responsibly to begin with.
meanwhile, those of us who continue to mask find this sort of plague rat shit repulsive in the extreme.
If you see no problem with referring to 99% of the population as plague rats then I don’t know what to tell you.
If you see taking basic precautions towards preventing an infectious disease as a ‘style choice’ then I suppose you can’t expect much patience and decorum from people who are especially at risk of its worst effects
Obviously the exceeding vast majority of people do not want to wear them. One look outside will tell you that. Me wearing one while healthy, and especially now while immune to COVID, does not change anything. Scolding the world will get us nowhere.
People should absolutely mask while experiencing symptoms, after having a possible exposure to COVID, or in a preventative manner before being around a vulnerable population. Vulnerable people should be able to mask without being harassed. If that is insufficient, blame the CDC for calling people and telling them to go back to work as soon as their fever subsides, not me individually for seeing it as fruitless to wear a mask while healthy while that is happening. I have debilitating symptoms of long COVID, I am being victimized by this shit too.
Finally, the vast majority of people are healthy, and I take issue with the world view that every person is a threat.
Clearly systemic approaches are the appropriate response to a pandemic. But our capitalist system has utterly failed to address this problem or put forth the most basic of solutions. So we must collectively work to protect one another in spite of their actions. Nobody is immune to Covid. Even as somebody who has gotten every vaccine the moment I could, I am susceptible to an infection, just much less so than somebody without the vaccines. Even if I got lucky and it was asymptomatic for me, I can act as a vector to spread it to somebody who is more at risk or just less lucky and who has major health outcomes for it. I’d much rather stick out in a crowd for masking than be the person responsible for passing the virus
It’s not about ‘viewing the world as a threat’ or ‘living in fear’ or whatever. It’s about community protection and mitigating the fallout of the ruling class’ selfish policies. The response of any revolutionary to systemic failures which are harming us should be collective action and education, and masks are a large part of that in the current climate of an ongoing pandemic. I wouldn’t look at the fact that millions of Americans vote for dems and repubs and conclude “the people want capitalism, I may as well give up on socialism.” Same principle should apply here
Thanks, that’s an interesting take.
99% of Americans would rather have all Palestinians get killed by Israel than see a 10% drop in the S&P 500 from arms divestment that’d be reflected in their retirement portfolio. Does that mean that communists have to bend over and not call out the bloodthirsty settlerbrained nonsense that the vast majority of people believe? Do we have to be nice to people who are committing violence against the disabled and elderly because they happen to be the overwhelming majority? Do we have to extend that politeness to online spaces that are supposed to be for likeminded people yet still appear to be full of the same plague rat mentality?
Really? I’ve seen a protest a week since Oct 6 and have participated in many, I didn’t get that vibe at all.
As I said above, I don’t think calling the overwhelming majority of people rats is as good a look as you think it is, nor do I think it will achieve the goal you want.
Yep, not to mention somewhere about 60-70% of Americans disapprove of Israel’s genocide. But the Uncommitted Movement just endorsed Kamala Harris. UAW had endorsed Joe Biden months ago after no concessions wrt Gaza. The distance between where western leftists lie and the radical actions that are actually necessary to stop the genocide of the Palestinian people, COVID, and climate collapse is immense. What do you think happens to that 60-70% figure when you break down the effects of the collapse of American empire? Do you think anywhere more than a miniscule number of Americans currently stand in solidarity with the aims of the Axis of Resistance of complete eradication of the Zionist entity and American presence from Western Asia? Or are they just sad because they saw Palestinians being murdered, but will just as easily become outraged by whatever propaganda tells them to be angry about China or Russia next?
What does this tell us about COVID? Upthread there is already criticism of the individualistic approach of criticizing non-mask-wearers and prescription of new measures for the COVID conscious community to demand. HEPA filters, better ventilation, etc. But the thing these issues have in common with the failure of western anti imperialism, is that if we can’t even get the basic knowledge across to a critical mass of people, as to make them make changes in their ordinary routines and daily behavior, then we obviously have a nearly impossible task ahead of us when tackling systems that have defence mechanisms built into them, much hardee defence mechanisms than simple force of habit.
Does that mean that the most effective strategy is to scream at people until they change their minds about the small stuff, then get together to scream about the big stuff? Obviously not, that strategy is ineffective on its own and I agree with you there. But when immunocompromised comrades’ lives are on the line, of couse I’ll scream at people who should get it because it’s patently absurd that I have to explain basic facts that we already understood a couple months into the pandemic to people that are supposed to be materialists.
Would you prefer “petri dish”? How 'bout “Nurglite”? There’s two immunocompromised people in my house, and a dozen in my personal orbit. Three of them have ALREADY been to the hospital over COVID. SEVEN OF THEM, MYSELF INCLUDED, have dealt with Long COVID symptoms after our infections passed.
I am beyond camaraderie or even so much as friendship, with anyone who’d further jeopardize the health and safety of my family. Plague. Rats. I’ll cross the street in front of you in public if I don’t see a mask on you, with the dirtiest look as I go by.
The logistics of this in the dense community where I live make this a very, very silly image.
I don’t think calling the vast majority of people rats is as good of a look as you think it is, nor do I think it effects the change you want.
You obviously don’t know me then, I don’t give the first fuck about optics in the eyes of crackers. I care about protecting the people I chose; and those who willingly carry pathogens and plagues in their faces are a tacit danger to me and my family.
I hope you have to live with the kind of lung scarring that my partner has to because crackers in my where wouldn’t mask. I hope you have to live with the kind of brainfog that my grandfather has to exist in if he tries to exert himself in the ways he used to before the pandemic.
I curse you with that.
Already have all that thanks 👍
Which comm am I in? Comradeship? Yea ok
Also yeah non-masking is famously a whites-only issue… U are the edgiest poster, all hail
the people coming here from hexbear should take a deep breath and realize we all went thru the shit during covid and that not everyone is american
Happy to hear alternate perspectives, actually came here for them in the first place
I am too, just without the hostility to other people, we can be talked to and hear other viewpoints without the vitriol. I myself have a shit ton of trauma related to COVID, people being mean to me is bringing that backup; as to why I deleted all my comments prior.
Catch covid, cracker. You are no comrade of mine, trying to argue over what I’ve had to live. Clearly, explaining it to you is useless; so just go experience it.
This “discussion”, for what little it was worth, is over.
U really showed me
Wishing covid on comrades is disgusting, grow up
What comrade? I don’t see one. Taking up for them, you disgust me too.