• Cowbee [he/him]@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    3 months ago

    Now here comes the next layer of propaganda. These so-called failed communist examples you speak of. Were any of them actually communism? Or were they just authoritarians calling themselves Communists to try to make people think they weren’t authoritarian?

    Sounds like you made it through the first and second layer, but stopped there and didn’t seek further knowledge. There are hundreds, thousands of layers of propaganda.

        • Pilferjinx@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          3 months ago

          Nah, true socialism was my very small community that basically traded favors and helped each other out. Legalized weed killed it. Idealoging from an armchair doesn’t do shit. Go out and make shit happen. It’s possible if you’re actually serious.

          • Cowbee [he/him]@lemmy.ml
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            3 months ago

            That was trade.

            I do agree that more leftists need to organize, PSL and FRSO are 2 seemingly good American orgs.

      • Cowbee [he/him]@lemmy.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        3 months ago

        The USSR did indeed have prisons, and criminals were put in prison. I never said the USSR was a wonderland with no prisons.

        • Olgratin_Magmatoe@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          3 months ago

          So are you saying it isn’t propaganda? Because the west depicts the gulags as forced labor camps, not just prisons. They are depicted as places where people starved to death through neglect, who were summarily executed upon failure to work, threatened with starvation. They are depicted as places where millions of people where held and died. They are also depicted as places where not just criminals were sent, but political prisoners as well.

          I’m not saying the west has perfectly depicted it. The west is absolutely rife with propaganda. But there being even a kernel of truth to this is downright horrifying, and cause to call out the USSR as being authoritarian.

          • Cowbee [he/him]@lemmy.ml
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            edit-2
            3 months ago

            So are you saying it isn’t propaganda? Because the west depicts the gulags as forced labor camps, not just prisons

            Prisons in the US are also often forced labor camps. Prisons in the USSR, like most nations, were highly varied in intensity and quality.

            They are depicted as places where people starved to death through neglect, who were summarily executed upon failure to work, threatened with starvation.

            The bulk of this comes from WWII, when the Nazis invaded Ukraine, the USSR’s breadbasket. Famine increased and prisoners were not prioritized, leading to many dying.

            They are depicted as places where millions of people where held and died. They are also depicted as places where not just criminals were sent, but political prisoners as well.

            Fascists and Capitalists were indeed also sent to prison, yes.

            I’m not saying the west has perfectly depicted it. The west is absolutely rife with propaganda. But there being even a kernel of truth to this is downright horrifying, and cause to call out the USSR as being authoritarian.

            By your logic, every state that has ever existed is authoritarian. Looking at the metrics, the USSR has been more progressive for its time, both with respect to contemporary states and with respect to Tsarist Russia. As an example, they were far more leniant than the Tsar:

            • Olgratin_Magmatoe@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              0
              ·
              edit-2
              3 months ago

              Prisons in the US are also often forced labor camps.

              This is a whataboutism. The USSR doesn’t get a free pass just because the U.S. is shitty too.

              The bulk of this comes from WWII, when the Nazis invaded Ukraine, the USSR’s breadbasket. Famine increased and prisoners were not prioritized, leading to many dying.

              Do you have a source? And given that you say “the bulk” and not all, what accounts for the remainder?

              Fascists and Capitalists were indeed also sent to prison, yes.

              Again, do you have a source?

              By your logic, every state that has ever existed is authoritarian.

              To varying degrees, pretty much yes.

              • Cowbee [he/him]@lemmy.ml
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                0
                ·
                3 months ago

                This is a whataboutism. The USSR doesn’t get a free pass just because the U.S. is shitty too.

                I was not giving the USSR a “free pass.” I was putting it into context. For its time, it was progressive.

                Do you have a source? And given that you say “the bulk” and not all, what accounts for the remainder?

                It’s well known among Soviet Historians that famine occured during WWII and Prisoners were forced to take the brunt of the impact, rather than the average citizen or soldier.

                Again, do you have a source?

                What do you believe constitutes a “Political Prisoner” in the USSR? There were numerous Nazi Collaborators, Tsarists, and Bourgeois elements that attempted to destabilize the State. What would satisfy you as evidence, just examples, or what?

                To varying degrees, pretty much yes.

                Then, genuine question, do you believe that making progressive, positive reductions in mortality rates is an authoritarian thing to do?

                • Olgratin_Magmatoe@lemmy.world
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  0
                  ·
                  3 months ago

                  I was not giving the USSR a “free pass.” I was putting it into context. For its time, it was progressive.

                  Force labor is still forced labor even if it is better than what the past was.

                  It’s well known among Soviet Historians that famine occured during WWII and Prisoners were forced to take the brunt of the impact, rather than the average citizen or soldier.

                  The graph you have attached to this statement doesn’t have a source listed. And sorry, but I’m no historian, so I would like something better than “it is well known”.

                  There were numerous Nazi Collaborators, Tsarists, and Bourgeois elements that attempted to destabilize the State. What would satisfy you as evidence, just examples, or what?

                  Ideally a primary source would be preferred.

                  Then, genuine question, do you believe that making progressive, positive reductions in mortality rates is an authoritarian thing to do?

                  This question at it’s core is a whataboutism and therefore invalid. Being a progressive authoritarian still means you’re an authoritarian.


                  Referring to the part of the conversation about the cause of starvation in gulags being the result of the nazis invading Ukraine, your second graph definitely helps support it, with the caveat being correlation does not imply causation.