Joint Statement from left leaning politicians criticising the new Budget.
Labour’s first budget punishes the “working people” they claim to support. Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves promised to deliver real change to the electorate, after 14 years of Tory rule. This week, they have broken that promise. This budget is austerity by another name.
While we welcome the government’s decision to invest in school and hospital buildings, it is extremely disappointing that these investments have been undermined by a swathe of public sector cuts, cruel attacks on the worst off, and a dogmatic refusal to redistribute wealth and power. These are not “tough choices” for government ministers, but for ordinary people who are forced to choose between heating their home and putting food on the table.
Labour is raising defence expenditure to 2.5% of GDP while telling us there is no money to lift 250,000 children out of poverty. This is a lie. There is plenty of money – it’s just in the wrong hands. The richest 1% in the UK hold more wealth than 70% of Britons. By refusing to impose a wealth tax, this government has chosen to force vulnerable communities to pay the price for years of economic failure, instead of making the richest pay their fair share. Labour’s first budget shows us whose side they’re on.
Years of austerity and privatisation have decimated our public services and pushed millions into poverty, disproportionately impacting women, people of colour and disabled people. Making millions of children, working, retired and disabled people poorer damages our entire economy and stretches our public services. An austerity economy is a false economy.
We, along with nearly 100 progressive Independent and Green politicians across the country, are calling on the Labour government to: 1) introduce wealth taxes; 2) abolish the two-child benefit cap and stop attacking welfare recipients; 3) reverse cuts to winter fuel; 4) restore the £2 bus cap; and 5) invest in a Green New Deal.
We refuse to believe that child poverty, mass hunger and homelessness are inevitable in the sixth largest economy in the world. A progressive movement is growing up and down the country, demanding a real alternative to this race to the bottom between Labour and the Tories, which has seen the new government perpetuate decades of austerity and rampant corporate greed.
The Tories’ collapse allowed Labour to come to power with the lowest vote share ever won by any single-party majority government. Labour haemorrhaging votes to progressive independents and Greens in their heartlands should be a lesson to this government: you are wrong to believe that progressive voters have nowhere else to go. Our movement is growing every day – and you ignore the demand for a real alternative at your peril.
– Jeremy Corbyn MP Independent, Carla Denyer MP Green party co-leader, Adrian Ramsay MP Green party co-leader, Sian Berry MP Green party, Ben Lake MP Plaid Cymru, Ann Davies MP Plaid Cymru, Liz Saville Roberts MP Plaid Cymru, Llinos Medi MP Plaid Cymru, Zack Polanski Green party deputy leader and London assembly member, Leanne Mohamad Independent candidate for Ilford North, Jamie Driscoll Former North of Tyne mayor, Andrew Feinstein Former ANC MP and Independent candidate for Holborn and St Pancras, Leanne Wood Former leader, Plaid Cymru, Beth Winter Former Labour MP for Cynon Valley, Hilary Schan Chair, We Deserve Better and Independent councillor in Worthing, Anthony Slaughter Wales Green party leader
“Austerity”. Lol.
Words have lost all meaning.
This is patently absurd. Labour already inherited the highest tax burden in 70 years from the Conservatives - this budget increases the tax burden by a further £40bn to fund extra spending. Government borrowing is also going to increase by an average of £32bn a year for the next five years due to this budget.
If this is what they call austerity, I’d hate to see what these people think government largesse looks like…
I think they are harming their argument by calling it “austerity” when the Budget is pumping money into hospitals and schools, starting to reverse the harm done by austerity. Yes I want them to go further but Corbyn did propose going further and lost the election. You have to be in power to enact change.
Labour haemorrhaging votes to progressive independents and Greens in their heartlands should be a lesson to this government: you are wrong to believe that progressive voters have nowhere else to go.
Here in Liverpool the Greens are second place to Labour in the majority of seats. I’d like them to win a few just to put Labour on notice that they can’t take vote for granted.
I think they are harming their argument by calling it “austerity” when the Budget is pumping money into hospitals and schools, starting to reverse the harm done by austerity.
I think reducing austerity to just underinvestment is letting Labour off too lightly. They promised no return to austerity and one of the key tenets of austerity was attacks on benefits recipients, especially disability benefits, and they haven’t reversed any of the planned Tory cuts to disability benefits. But don’t get me wrong, I’m glad for the increased investment in public services, god knows they need it.
This is actually an abridged version of the full statement, which they haven’t released a text version of anywhere because apparently uploading jpegs of text to Twitter is how we do politics now.
Full thing
Labour’s first budget punishes the “working people” they claim to support.
Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves promised to deliver real change to the electorate, after 14 years of Tory rule. Today, they have broken that promise. This budget is austerity by another name. While we welcome the government’s decision to invest in school and hospital buildings, it is extremely disappointing that these investments have been undermined by a swathe of public sector cuts, cruel attacks on the worst-off, and a dogmatic refusal to redistribute wealth and power. These are not “tough choices” for Government Ministers, but for ordinary people who are forced to choose between heating their home and putting food on the table.
Years of austerity and privatisation have decimated our public services and pushed millions into poverty, disproportionately impacting women, people of colour and disabled people. The collapse of the Tory government was an opportunity for Labour to end the grotesque levels of inequality reached under the Tories. Instead, they have chosen to inflict more hardship on the British public who expected - and deserved - something better.
Labour is raising defence expenditure to 2.5% of GDP while telling us there is no money to lift 250,000 children out of poverty; no money to help pensioners living in poverty stay warm this winter; and no money to maintain the £2 bus cap which punishes the poorest for trying to get to work and go about their lives.
Put simply, this is a lie. There is plenty of money. It’s just in the wrong hands. The richest 1% in the UK hold more wealth than 70 per cent of Britons. By refusing to impose a wealth tax, this Government has chosen to force vulnerable communities to pay the price for years of economic failure, instead of making the richest pay their fair share. Labour’s first budget shows us whose side they’re on.
Making millions of children, working, retired and disabled people poorer damages our entire economy and stretches our public services. An austerity economy is a false economy.
Shifting the fiscal rules to increase investment is welcome but this should have been used to tackle inequality and maximise the creation of good jobs. As we saw in the New Labour years, growth does not necessarily deliver for the majority - reducing poverty and inequality while tackling the climate emergency should have dictated Labour’s policy choices. Instead the Chancellor has wedded us to a failed economic ideology and undermined our ability to fix this country.
We call on the Labour Government to:
- Abolish the 2-child benefits cap and stop attacking welfare recipients;
More than two thirds of children in poverty live with a parent in work. We must support, not stigmatise, welfare recipients. Since the election, more than 10,000 children have been pushed into poverty by the two-child limit. Abolishing the cap would cost £1.4bn and lift 250,000 children out of poverty overnight. If this isn’t a priority, what is? - Reverse cuts to winter fuel;
Four in every five pensioners living below or just above the poverty line are set to lose the winter fuel payment. We will always defend the principle of universalism to ensure everyone has the support they need. - Restore the £2 bus cap;
Scrapping the £2 bus fare cap outside of London harms the poorest in communities across England and discourages the use of public transport when it is needed more than ever to tackle the climate crisis. - Invest in a Green New Deal;
The climate emergency is the single greatest crisis of our time. Why, then, has the government reneged on its £28bn climate pledge, while continuing a Tory scheme to give £21.7 billion in public funds to subsidise the world’s largest fossil fuel companies for carbon capture and storage when we know this doesn’t work. We will continue to demand urgent investment in renewable energy and green jobs to safeguard our children’s future. - Introduce wealth taxes;
A 2% tax on wealth above £10 million would raise £24bn every year. With that, you could abolish the 2-child benefits cap 17 times over. There is plenty of money. It’s just in the wrong hands.
We refuse to believe that child poverty, mass hunger and homelessness are inevitable in the sixth largest economy in the world. A progressive movement is growing up and down the country, demanding a real alternative to this race to the bottom between Labour and the Tories which has seen the new government perpetuate decades of austerity and rampant corporate greed.
The Tories’ collapse allowed Labour to come to power with the lowest vote share ever won by any single party majority government. Labour hemorrhaging votes to progressive independents and Greens in their heartlands should be a lesson to this Government: you are wrong to believe that progressive voters have nowhere else to go. Our movement is growing every day - and you ignore the demand for a real alternative at your peril.
Signatories
Signed,
Jeremy Corbyn MP, independent
Carla Denyer MP, Green Party Co-Leader
Adrian Ramsay MP, Green Party Co-Leader
Sian Berry MP, Green Party Leanne Wood, former leader of Plaid Cymru
Liz Saville Roberts MP, Plaid Cymru
Ben Lake MP, Plaid Cymru
Llinos Medi MP, Plaid Cymru
Ann Davies MP, Plaid Cymru
Zack Polanski, Green Party Deputy Leader and London Assembly Member
Leanne Mohamad, Independent candidate for Ilford North
Jamie Driscoll, Leader of Majority and Independent former North of Tyne Mayor
Andrew Feinstein, former ANC MP and independent candidate for Holborn & St Pancras
Beth Winter, former Labour MP for Cynon Valley
Cllr Hilary Schan, Chair of We Deserve Better and independent councillor, Worthing Borough Council
Anthony Slaughter, Wales Green Party Leader
Zoë Garbett, Green London Assembly Member and councillor, Hackney Council
Caroline Russell, Green London Assembly Member and councillor, Islington Council
Cllr Amna Abdullatif, independent, Manchester City Council
Cllr Carl Walker, independent, Worthing Borough Council
Cllr Suleman Khonat, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Salim Sidat MBE, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Mustafa Desai, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Muntazir Patel, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Salma Patel, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Sajid Ali, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Terry Mahmood, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Imran Ahmed, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Rana Gulistan, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Mohamed Kapadia, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Iqbal Masters, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Waqar Hussain, independent, Blackburn Council
Cllr Ammar Anwar, independent, Kirklees Council
Cllr Tanisha Bramwell, independent, Kirklees Council
Cllr Imran S Safdar, independent, Kirklees Council
Cllr Emma Dent Coad, independent, Kensington and Chelsea Council
Cllr Yvonne Tennant, independent, Pendle Borough Council
Cllr Chris Davies, Green Party, South Tyneside Council
Cllr Holly Wadell, independent, Northumberland County Council
Cllr Benali Hamdache, Green Party, Islington Council
Cllr Jonathan Elmer, Green Party, Durham County Council.
Cllr Margaret Howard, independent, Worthing Borough Council
Cllr Claire Hunt, Green Party, Worthing Borough Council
Cllr Ian Davey, Green Party, Worthing Borough Council
Cllr Penny Wrout, independent, Hackney Council
Cllr Claudia Turbet-Delof, independent, Hackney Council
Cllr Fliss Premru, independent, Hackney Council
Cllr Alexi Dimond, Green Party, Sheffield Council
Cllr Nick Hartley, Green Party, Newcastle City Council
Cllr Mary Murphy, independent, Northumberland County Council
Cllr Ray Sutton, independent, North West Leicestershire Council
Cllr Sophia Naqvi, independent, Newham Council
Cllr Mehmood Mirza, independent, Newham Council
Cllr Zubair Gulamussen, independent, Newham Council
Cllr Nathanial Higgins, Green Party, Newham Council
Cllr Russell Whiting, independent, Gedling Borough Council
Cllr Dr Hosnieh Djafari-Marbini, independent, Oxford Council
Cllr Scott Ainslie, Green Party, Lambeth Council
Cllr Sean Halsall, independent, Sefton Council
Cllr Asima Shaikh, independent, Islington Council
Cllr Ilkay Cindi-Oner, independent, Islington Council
Cllr Phil Graham, independent, Islington Council
Cllr Matt Nathan, independent, Islington Council
Cllr Ani Stafford-Townsend, Green Party, Bristol City Council
Cllr Ria Patel, Green Party, Croydon Council
Cllr Khaled Musharraf, Green Party, Newcastle City Council
Cllr James Crawford, Green Party, Bristol City Council
Cllr Liam Davis, Green Party, Hackney Council
Cllr Kerry Picket, Green Party, Brighton & Hove City Council
Cllr Ernestas Jegorovas- Armstrong, Green Party, Islington Council
Cllr Alastair Binnie-Lubbock, Green Party, Hackney Council
Cllr Ben Foley, Green Party, Bedford Borough Council
Cllr Habib Rahman, independent, Newcastle City Council
Cllr Alan Gibbons, independent, Liverpool City Council
Cllr Sam Gorst, independent, Liverpool City Council
Cllr Lucy Williams, independent, Liverpool City Council
Cllr Karen Davis, independent, Norwich City Council
Cllr Cate Oliver, independent, Norwich City Council
Cllr Pete Kennedy, Green Party, Stroud District Council
Cllr Paul Barnett, independent, Hastings Borough Council
Cllr Andy Batsford, independent, Hastings Borough Council
Cllr John Cannan, independent, Hastings Borough Council
Cllr Nigel Sinden, independent, Hastings Borough Council
Cllr Mike Turner, independent, Hastings Borough Council
Cllr Simon Willis, independent, Hastings Borough Council
Cllr Hau-Yu Tam, independent, Lewisham Council
Cllr Chloë Goldsmith, Green Party, Brighton & Hove City Council
Cllr Raphael Hill, Green Party, Brighton & Hove City Council
Cllr Lotte Collett, independent, Haringey Council
Cllr Jane McCoid, independent, Gateshead Council
- Abolish the 2-child benefits cap and stop attacking welfare recipients;